First came the ratings, served on the show's signature scale: Burnt to Chewy. Luke, the resident cinephile, gave it a 6, calling parts of it "schmaltzy" but praising Will Smith's raw, real performance. Nate landed at a 5, admiring the film's message about persistence even when the storyline left him with questions. Marty went highest with a 7, choosing to look past the plot holes and feel the emotional roller coaster of a father who refused to quit.