First came the ratings, served on the show's signature scale: Burnt to Chewy. Luke, the resident cinephile, gave it a 6, calling parts of it "schmaltzy" but praising Will Smith's raw, real performance. Nate landed at a 5, admiring the film's message about persistence even when the storyline left him with questions. Marty went highest with a 7, choosing to look past the plot holes and feel the emotional roller coaster of a father who refused to quit.

If there’s one thing this episode proved, it’s that kindness is timeless. Marty couldn’t even get these two to argue! Their playful banter about karaoke songs and favorite musicals was a masterclass in how to communicate with warmth and humor. Chris’s advice to “be curious and open-minded” and Lauren’s suggestion to “pretend you know nothing and ask questions” are lessons we can all take to heart.